T.I.’s hymen comments reflect society’s ‘antiquated view’ of virginity: experts


Earlier this month, rapper T.I. revealed in a now-deleted episode of the podcast Ladies Like Us that he would take his 18-year-old daughter Deyjah Harris to the gynecologist every year to see if her hymen was “still intact.”

The rapper’s comments prompted outrage on social media sites, which the 39-year-old addressed in an interview with Jada Pinkett Smith on Monday.

“I think that a lot of people kind of took it extremely literal … I honestly thought people knew me better than that,” he said.

When asked if he understood the sensitivity around the comments, T.I. admitted at the time he didn’t, but he does now.

READ MORE: T.I. makes sure his daughter’s hymen is ‘intact,’ experts say that’s problematic

The conversation evolved to one of parenting at large, during which T.I. said he was “willing to go above and beyond to protect” his daughter. He noted this “protection” meant being aware of the “slimy little boys” who want to “defile and destroy the sanctity I have.”

Story continues below advertisement

And in regards to comments around his daughter’s virginity, the rapper added since she turned 18, he no longer has control “of anything.” He went on to say though, that a parent’s role, in his mind, is still important.

“There has to be someone there to clarify what is acceptable, what is unacceptable … I trust and believe that I put moral standards, principles and greatness in all of my children. But until they know how to unlock it and use those powers themselves, it has to be harnessed.”

Ford opens up website for parents to ‘snitch’ on teachers

Ford opens up website for parents to ‘snitch’ on teachers

Smith asked the rapper how he would feel if his daughter had lost her virginity at 15 or 16.

“Childhood ends when you lose your virginity,” he said. “You ended your childhood and attempt to begin adulthood.”

Smith’s mother and co-host Adrienne Banfield-Norris asked if the rapper’s sons and daughters’ virginity was seen differently.

If my son goes out and gets a girl pregnant, how is the household changed for those nine months?” he asked. “The household does not necessarily change those in nine months … where if my daughter comes home, the household changes immediately. We were raised to provide and protect.”

The history of virginity

The way T.I. talks about his daughter’s virginity, says Queen’s University family medicine professor Dr. Susan Phillips, seems “rooted in ownership of women — whether by their husbands or their fathers.”

Story continues below advertisement

The idea of ownership is why the World Health Organization (WHO) and other United Nations agencies called for a worldwide ban on the practice of “virginity testing” in October.

Defined by the WHO as “a gynecological examination conducted under the belief that it determines whether a woman or girl has had vaginal intercourse,” virginity testing historically been used as an means of oppression around the world.

“There is no evidence that either method can prove whether a woman or girl has had vaginal intercourse or not,” the organization said.

The WHO said the test is both “medically unnecessary” and “violates several human rights,” recommending that doctors no longer perform the procedure to protect the safety of women and girls.

Story continues below advertisement

Phillips also finds other problems with T.I.’s comments and the idea of virginity testing.

“It also reverts to an antiquated view of the value of a woman being lowered by not being a virgin. To further seek an outside source of this information also betrays a total lack of trust in his daughter,” Phillips said.

“First, why wouldn’t he just ask her and, more importantly, is [her sexual activity] really any [of] his business?”

READ MORE: T.I. defends controversial comments about his daughter’s hymen

That a woman would be considered “less than” or “worse” after she has sex for the first time is a discriminatory practice used throughout history to further oppress women as a group.

Unfortunately, T.I.’s comments suggest that this idea hasn’t evolved much over time.

“This focus on women’s virginity is, in my opinion, a reflection of ongoing stereotypical attitudes about women’s sexuality — such as discriminatory beliefs about the moral status of sexually active women,” said Elaine Brooks-Craig, an associate professor of law at Dalhousie University in Halifax.

“The policing and surveillance of women’s sexuality by fathers and husbands reinforces outdated and harmful constructions of women’s bodies as men’s properties.”

Tweet This

‘Virginity’ is a myth

Virginity or “being a virgin” is not a medical term — there is no way to measure one’s virginity.

Story continues below advertisement

Previously speaking with Global News, relationship and sex expert Jessica O’Reilly, host of the @SexWithDrJessPodcast, says virginity is a social construct, the importance of which is over-emphasized for girls and women.

“Virginity tends to be overemphasized based on gender, with young women pressured to maintain their so-called virginity and young men to claim they’ve lost their so-called virginity,” she said.

3 former St. Michael’s College School students back in court for sex assault case

3 former St. Michael’s College School students back in court for sex assault case

“It really reduces sex to one specific act.”

Tweet This

This is reinforced in popular culture, says O’Reilly. Young women, in particular, have talked about claiming virginity, while men talk about losing theirs.

“This type of behaviour from T.I. just reeks of men owning women’s bodies and fathers having more agency over their daughters’ bodies than the daughters themselves.”

Previously speaking with Global News, Laura M. Carpenter, a sociology professor at Vanderbilt University and author of Virginity Lost: An Intimate Portrait of First Sexual Experiences, said virginity for women is seen as “necessary.”

“Historically, we’ve seen female virginity as more necessary, as almost tantalizing, and there’s this sort of myth or narrative in the culture of men wanting to introduce women to … the wonders of sex,” Carpenter said.

READ MORE: T.I. defends controversial comments about his daughter’s hymen

Perpetuating the myth of virginity harms girls and women

By focusing on one’s virginity and whether they’ve “lost it,” girls and women lose out on the part of the conversation where they’re able to learn about their bodies and become fully sexually developed.

Story continues below advertisement

O’Reilly stresses we really need to stop focusing so much on the hymen. The hymen is thin mucous tissue folds — it is not a solid membrane that “pops” during vaginal sex, she said.

“It can be worn over time through a variety of processes, including hormonal changes, your menstruation, regular discharge or masturbation.”

READ MORE: Only 1 in 10 substantiated sexual assaults result in conviction, StatsCan says

O’Reilly says there are better ways to have open conversations about sex.

“Teaching your kids their only option is to abstain and policing your child’s body does not make them safer,” she explained. “It does not help to instill body confidence and positive body image in young people, which I would think most parents desire.”

— With files from Arti Patel and Laura Hensley



© 2019 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.